Best Bread Machine Reviews 2019 – Buyer’s Guide

Best Bread MachineHi there! I’m John, welcome to my best bread machine reviews blog. Now, normally I’d tell you that you should be baking your bread the old fashioned way, kneading the dough by hand, letting it rise and then baking it in your oven.

But I know that in today’s world, we don’t have as much time for all of this kind of thing like we used to, but there are still times when we crave for delicious, homemade bread in the mornings before work or school. So? Get the best bread machine and problem solved!

I own many best bread makers or bread machines but I can’t possibly test every one of them, but I do hope that my sharing and research will be helpful for you to find your best bread machine here:)

How To Choose The Best Bread Machine?

Size and Shape of Bread Machine

Some bread machines are tall while some are long, choose one that will fit in your kitchen. One of the main problem bread machine owners face is the lack of space to put or store the bread machine. If space is a problem you would want to look for a compact bread machine or one with a small footprint.

Size Of Loaves

Besides that, the capacity of the bread machine will also count for something. A quick look at the pan in the bread machine will give one a rough idea of the size of the loaves. Don’t buy one that is too large because homemade bread does not last as long as store brought bread due to its lack of preservatives. But do keep in mind that the bread consumption of your family may probably increase once you start making delicious homemade bread, so choose a slightly larger size.

Best Bread Machines Recommendation Sorted By Size:

Settings

Always check the settings of the model you are intending to buy. The specifications are quite important, because they will determine what you can or cannot do with your bread machine. Here are some of the settings you might want your bread machine to include:

  • Delay timer – Ingredients can be placed in the bread machine overnight and fresh bread can be had for breakfast.
  • Dough setting – A bread maker that will only make the dough and not bake it as well can make dough for pizza and other baked goods.
  • Window – For the diligent user who likes to check on the bread.
  • Keep warm – If you think you won’t be there when the bread is done, keep warm option is nice to keep your bread warm and tasty until you come back.
  • Bread cycles – Different cycles like whole wheat, French bread, gluten-free and more.

Warranty & Durability

The last thing to remember and to check for is a good warranty and service options to safeguard your investment should anything go wrong.

Best Bread Machine – My Top Picks

I checked some out, asked my friends about them and did some of my own research on the Internet to help you guys decide which is the best bread machine model for you. There are many out there but I’ve only chosen the best to recommend to you. I hope you’ll be able to use these bread machine reviews to your advantage:)

Bread machine or bread maker is just the simplest way to create a loaf of bread; it works just like a rice cooker. All you need to do is put in the ingredients, set the timer and press the button. It is much easier than baking bread using any other bake-ware.

Best Bread Machine 2019

Model MaterialLoaf sizes
(lbs)
Weight
(lbs)
Price
Zojirushi BB-HAC10Stainless Steel1.015.0 Check Price
Panasonic SD YD250Plastic2.515.4 Check Price
Zojirushi BB-CEC20
(Editor's Choice)
Stainless Steel2.020.0 Check Price
Breadman TR875Plastic2.07.05 Check Price
Sunbeam 5891Plastic2.018.6 Check Price
West Bend 41300Aluminum2.015.7 Check Price
Cuisinart CBK-100
Plastic2.018.0 Check Price
Oster 5838Plastic2.08.0 Check Price
Cuisinart CBK-200Stainless Steel2.016.0 Check Price

1. Zojirushi BB-HAC10 Bread MachineZojirushi BB-HAC10 Bread Machine

Zojirushi has really been a great company to supply kitchens worldwide with the ability to make fresh bread through their array of automated bread makers.

I trust only them to provide me with perfect gluten free bread, and now it seems that they have made a mini size bread maker especially for small families and those who do not consume bread as a staple during their meals.

Using this Bread Machine

Well I’d say I would use this if I didn’t have to make at least 2 lbs of bread for a single session, but this works very well when I’m too lazy to get my larger and more versatile bread makers out, not that this tiny one is not versatile enough (no programming? Oh no!).

So anyway, just like you would any other bread maker, you place in the ingredients in, yeast powder and liquids, but no fruit, and if you are using the delay start you should never ever use dairy, asking why would be like asking what happens if you were to leave milk out on the counter for more than 20 minutes.

The buttons here are all labeled respectively, so just choose what type of bread you are making and the LCD display will show the always present countdown and temperature, nothing to worry about since you can’t change any of that.

This bread machine has all the regular things you would expect, the only difference would be the size of bread you can produce, this little dough puncher can whip out a maximum of 1pound, cake or bread, whichever you fancy.

The regular dough maker functions like pizza and cookie are ever present (I rarely use them but I guess it’s a bonus). The quick bake cycle produces a fantastic loaf in just less than 2 hours, not as fast as others but I can say that there is no compromise in the texture or taste.

Nice Size, Not so Nice Looks

Now with all that aside let’s take a look at the cosmetic details of this bread maker. A big and obvious win would be the size, it’s small and so compact that you could store it, display it and even use it in one spot. A big bummer about the looks is that it has none, it plain white just like other Zojirushi, but due to its size it seems very plain and unappealing, I didn’t like the way the edges would make it look like something round.

The see through window on top is nothing to be surprised with, but it actually makes it look rather cute, if the unit did not have this I would have thought it was not too far from being a revolting sight. It also comes with a carrying handle.

The kneading paddle and the baking pan are both nonstick, the build is fairly secure but it would still be safe to clean under the paddle to prevent buildup.

For the end of the review I would say that I am satisfied with this Zojirushi BB-HAC10 bread maker, it’s small and it bakes just as well as anyone could. I would give this to a pair of newlyweds or when my kids are old enough to have a place of their own.

2. Panasonic SD YD250 – Best Big Bread MachinePanasonic SD YD250

This Panasonic SD YD250 Automatic Bread Machine makes the biggest loaves of the whole bunch! 2.5 lbs loaves of bread for breakfast, anyone? If you’re looking for a bread machine for your large family, then I do believe this is the bread machine for you.

If you don’t want to make enormous loaves of bread all the time, well there are 3 settings of bread size that you can choose. You can also choose white, whole-wheat, multigrain, French or quickbread/cakes settings.

Quickbread is for bread that doesn’t require yeast, such as banana bread or gingerbread. And you know that everybody loves banana bread! But you don’t have the recipe? No fear. It comes with a 40-recipe booklet, which I’m sure will come in handy.

It Works For Me

I personally think that the 13-hour delay timer worked a charm. If you’re in the industry like I am and go to work to knead dough all day, you don’t want to do the same when you come home. So I put in all the ingredients for whatever bread I feel like eating tomorrow for breakfast, and when I wake up I can make delicious, nutritious sandwiches for my 3 kids, with no fuss at all!

Is Big Better?

There is one thing though. It’s a big machine. My kitchen is wonderfully spacious, but I know that not everyone has the luxury of a big kitchen, so before thinking of buying this Panasonic sd yd250 bread maker, remember that it’s 14 x 13.5 x 9 inches, which is pretty big for a bread machine. But if you do have space, and you need huge loaves to feed your hungry brood every morning, well, this is the machine for you.

3. Zojirushi BB-CEC20 – Best Bread MachineZojirushi BB-CEC20

Zojirushi BB-CEC20 has finally replaced its counterpart the BBCCX-20. This bread machine was built to be similar to its sister model. It makes perfect bread every time and is great for making gluten-free bread and pizza crust. I highly recommend this bread machine as it is now the best.

Loved the Shape

The very first thing that anyone would love about this bread machine is the shape of the loaf that it turns out. Since it sits on its long side, the bread comes out actually looking like it was oven-baked instead of that tall, weird thing with a rounded top.

Versatile, Convenient, and Makes Delicious Bread

You can program this bread maker for how long it takes each step so that the gluten-free loaf turns out perfect. Of course, you can also make whole wheat bread, meatloaf, jam, cake, cinnamon rolls or breadsticks! Just use one of the 10 pre-programmed cycles. This versatility means that anyone, whether a seasoned baker or a first timer, can find settings to fit themselves.

The best thing about having a bread machine that has a delay timer is that you can have fresh bread for breakfast or tea every day, but not having to wake up early to bake it. In fact, if you overslept, the machine keeps the bread warm up to half an hour for you. I am so pleasantly surprised at this thoughtful feature!

At any other time, you can just put everything into the machine, and leave it to do its work while you have hours of free time to do whatever you want, which would have been used to mix, knead, wait for rising and punching dough, if you were doing it yourself. You also don’t have to heat up your kitchen with a big oven. And the bread made by this bread machine will be just as good as what you make yourself!

The two kneading paddles are wonderful. Anyone who bakes bread knows that when you get delicious bread in the end most of the credit goes to the kneading process, and having two instead of one paddle means you can be sure to have a great loaf!

Cleaning Up

For the whole baking process, you will only need to clean up a few things afterward: the included measuring cup and spoon, and the baking pan. The pan is non-stick so bread slides out without leaving a trace. If you hate having a hole in your loaf and bits of bread on the paddle, try taking out the paddle when the dough has risen for the last time and before the baking begins.

Buy?

The ultimate question, should you buy? Well, I think at $220 the Zojirushi BB-CEC20 is maybe slightly expensive for some, but all the wonderful features and the lovely bread that it turns out to make it worth the money spent. After all you’ll be saving money and staying healthy by eating homemade bread in the long run!

4. Breadman TR875 2-Pound Bread MachineBreadman TR875 2-Pound Bread Machine

The simple wonder of bread making, made easier with automated bread machines, back in the days when hand kneading and ovens were the only way to make a good loaf of bread, an automated bread maker would have been considered wizardry, but not today as you can find quite a number of them, and cheap too.

A good example of a cheap but branded bread maker would be this large and not so in the charge bread machine.

Breadman TR875 has caused a lot of mixed reviews on Amazon, some love it and drop a generous amount of stars while swearing to never ever used anything else besides this, while others would prefer to tie it to a rock and toss it into the Hudson River.

Well it will be hard to tell which of these reviews are true so I decided to take it on myself to do a review.

Gluten-free Bread

The first thing I noticed when I bought the bread maker is that it doesn’t look half bad, the stainless steel body and the display, all complemented by the black coloration, the design was really nice as well. After a few minutes of finding the perfect spot on my counter to maximize the vista of this maker I finally went through the manual, the moment I saw the Gluten free page my mind began to hover on one review which said it didn’t work well, so I decided to try it out first.

I made a small 1-1/2 lbs mix and followed the recipe book by the letter (with a few reductions and increase here and there), after a few hours the bread was done, I did notice it was a little more wet than if I were to use my BBCCX20 from Zojirushi, but the bread was not chewy and it was ok.

Pretty Good Features for a Budget Bread Machine

Breadman TR875 comes with all the regulars that you were to expect from a bread maker, an LCD display, a paddle (of course), nonstick dough pan and a see through window, which I personally favor since I can take a look at the mixing and baking to assure myself that it’s doing fine.

The other functions that were available were all regular ones that you would find on other break makers, like pizza and French bread, the one I liked the most is the delay start which acts just like a slow cooker, only thing is it only turns on after the programmed amount of time has passes, I use this function the night before so my family can enjoy fresh bread in the morning, I set it for 6 hours at 11 and wake up at 7 for some freshly baked bread.

Almost anything can be done with this bread maker, quite surprising for something under $70 on Amazon, and another feature which I seldom use but appreciate would be the fruit and nut signal which lets me know when I need to pour in that cup of almonds and raisins.

Not Sure It’ll Last Long

However, this breadmaker is a little flimsy. I haven’t had any problem with the electronics but I would say if your Breadman wasn’t functioning properly then you may have a problem with the electronics, not a big surprise with something as digital and complicated as this. Another concern would be the paddle getting jammed, I have gone through my fair share of bread makers and yes I have had a few jammed, but this is entirely due to having flour getting caught up under the paddle and turning stiff.

So if you are looking for a cheap affordable and particularly fancy bread maker with a lot of functions then you can try your luck at buying the Breadman TR875, but be careful not to receive the refurbished ones as I cannot guarantee how they will turn out.

5. Sunbeam 5891 2-Pound Bread Machine – Best Value Bread MachineSunbeam 5891 2-Pound Bread Machine

This Sunbeam 5891 is a pretty good model for its price. I always thought that the better bread machines always cost more than US$100, but the Sunbeam costs less, but is still feature-packed.

I couldn’t believe how cheap this bread machine was. But then again, as a baker myself, I personally wouldn’t go for the inexpensive model because I can afford better. However, if you’re new to bread making generally, and using a bread machine specifically, then I think you should give this model a try.

My only grouse with this Sunbeam 5891 is the included recipe booklet. Don’t use it! They put waaaay too much yeast in everything, resulting in sunken tops and uncooked bread. Look for other bread machine recipes online or buy a bread machine recipe book.

With the interest in bread machines nowadays, these books won’t be hard to find. I myself have two because they make it so much easier to make bread.

The Bottom Line: To Buy, or not to Buy?

Give this machine a try if you’re an amateur or you think you’ll not be using your bread machine very much anyway. You’ll be very pleased with the price, and the results, because this baby has pretty good settings and features packed into the price.

Don’t buy it if… well, I can’t think of anything. Okay, maybe that it’s not exactly dishwasher safe. And the recipe booklet isn’t very good.

But generally, it’s a pretty good bread machine.

6. West Bend 41300 Hi-Rise Electronic Dual-Blade BreadmakerWest Bend 41300 Hi-Rise Electronic Dual-Blade Breadmaker

You know you’ve got a superb bread maker when the bread turns out looking golden-brown lovely, smelling reminiscent of childhood, and tasting just right. And you know you’ve got a bargain when that bread machine doesn’t cost more than $85.

The West Bend 41300 Hi-Rise is that bread machine. It is not the high end Zojirushi, nor is it a popular Breadman, but it produces tasty horizontal loaves and a great many baking options at an affordable price, and that’s what is important.

It is also simple to use – just measure the ingredients into the pan, press button and go do other stuff while it bakes the bread for you. The dual blades knead ever so well, the dough rises beautifully for light and fluffy bread, and it beeps when it’s time to add fruits and nuts.

Basically, all bread machines need you to add in fruits and nuts later on, except for the really high end ones that have a seed dispenser.

Despite the price, this bread machine is made with quality and doesn’t jitter or walk on the countertop while it kneads, but remember to place it on a firm and solid surface. The dough doesn’t stick on the sides as well, making it a breeze to clean.

A tip for the new user: break in your West Bend 41300 Hi-Rise by running the bake cycle once before you bake any bread. This is to remove any stink from the new machine.

The West Bend 41300 Hi-Rise Electronic Dual-Blade Breadmaker has great value for money. It’ll soon pay for itself by saving you all that money buying bread and ordering pizza.

7. Cuisinart CBK-100 Programmable BreadmakerCuisinart CBK-100 Programmable Breadmaker

Cuisinart CBK-100 Programmable Breadmaker is the best bread machine for the gluten-free diet. It makes the best tasting gluten-free bread, according to a few reviewers.

Apparently, it is difficult to buy ready-made gluten-free bread that is tasty, so a bread machine is a way to go. Cuisinart CBK-100 makes such tasty gluten-free bread that many reviewers have praised it for that.

One said that the gluten free cycle is perfect. It bakes the best gluten free bread with Gluten free pantry Sandwich bread mix (a couple of users have recommended this) and Bob’s Red Mill gluten free multigrain mix.

The bread that results is light and the crust is perfect. It is easy to slice and tastes delicious. If you want to bake gluten free bread, this is the bread machine for you.

This bread maker beeps loudly for you to remove the paddle (so that it doesn’t leave a hole in the bread), and again when the bread is done. This can be a drawback for anyone who wants to use the time delay to bake bread at night.

The recipes that come with the machine is nice for some users but doesn’t include gluten-free recipes. There are voices on the non-existing manual but it appears that there are instructions on the Amazon page and probably on the Cuisinart website as well.

Also, you always have to use lukewarm liquids (not hot or cold) for the bread to rise properly.

Well, things can’t be perfect, and Cuisinart CBK-100 Programmable Breadmaker only costs $90, which is a good bargain for those who crave some delicious gluten-free bread.

8. Oster 5838 ExpressBake Bread Machine – Best Express Bread MachineOster 5838 ExpressBake Bread Machine

Can you believe that you can get bread in as little as 58 minutes? I didn’t. Well, not until I found the Oster 5838 ExpressBake Breadmaker. I’m a stickler for tradition, and when I found out about how quick this machine makes bread, I was at first put off by the idea. How can any machine make bread that quick and still ensures it’s great?

I’ve since changed my opinion because this bread machine really does make good-tasting bread in 58 minutes. I timed it.

The viewing window really helped me see what it is that I was baking, and when I took my loaf of bread out, it looked like a loaf of bread should, not like other bread machines, which produce weird-looking loaves that taste like bread, smells like bread, but don’t really look like bread at all.

It has 18-settings for different types of bread, a 13-hour delayed cycle, 3 bread size settings and of course, the famous 58-minute ExpressBake cycle.

It’s also a pretty inexpensive purchase, because it’s less than US$100, so even without the ExpressBake cycle, it’s a pretty affordable bread machine.

Quick! Is Express Bread Worth It?

I think it is. Sometimes you just don’t have the time. Or when the fancy strikes you, nothing is more instantly gratifying than a loaf of bread in under an hour.

9. Cuisinart CBK-200 2-Pound Convection Automatic Bread MakerCuisinart CBK-200 2-Pound Convection Automatic Bread Maker

This Cuisinart CBK-200 convection bread machine is probably one of the most controversial, with heaps of rave reviews on one end and not lacking bad comments on the other.

The Good Side:

This bread machine kneads really well, so says J. Hrametz, an experienced bread baker with or without machines, at Amazon. This could be due to the solid construction of the bread machine and its weight. It is good looking on the counter too, and the convection helps with the thoroughness of the baking.

Another reviewer says that the crust comes out exactly as you want it, and that is important to some.

This Cuisinart bread machine has a combination of the following good features, which the Breadman or Zojirushi bread machine may not have:

  • a low carb cycle
  • a beep to remove paddle
  • horizontal loaf
  • jam cycle
  • pause option
  • power failure backup
  • convection fan

The Bad Side:

Some experienced bakers like J. Hrametz would like to use different risings and so on to tweak their loaves, but this bread machine doesn’t allow that. Once you start a cycle you cannot stop it. Even if you turn it off, the program does not reset. So if you are the kind of baker who wants flexibility, this is not a good bread machine for you.

Another reviewer said that this machine is not the kind where you put in the ingredients, then go away and come back for a perfect loaf of bread every time. The user needs to check what’s happening with the bread maker.

Many of the negative reviews could have stemmed from getting faulty machines, but they may also have been due to high expectations such as wanting the bread machine to totally hands off automatic or expecting it to be as quiet as a whisper. This bread machine is only averagely silent, as a reviewer said.

Conclusion

I would say that the Cuisinart CBK-200 2-Pound Convection Automatic Bread Maker is a great bread machine, and it actually does have a pause option if you read the manual carefully. Obviously, you have to come back to it to add fruit and nuts if you like, and remove the paddle to avoid that big hole in the bread. So what’s the fuss about it not being fully automatic if it produces really good bread? Plus, it only costs around $150, which is a great buy. Recommended!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *